Summary
Crop productivity relies on synthetic nitrogen fertilizers, which entail significant economic and environmental costs. Engineering crop plants to produce nitrogenase allowing them to acquire nitrogen from the atmosphere offers a transformative approach to sustainable agriculture. However, engineering the nitrogenase pathway into eukaryotic cells poses significant challenges due to the enzyme metal clusters, high energy demands, and extreme sensitivity to oxygen. This review summarizes recent advances in nitrogenase engineering in yeast and plants. Progress has been made using a stepwise modular approach and a functional validation pipeline for core and ancillary nitrogenase proteins. Key milestones include the production of active NifH and NifB proteins in mitochondria and chloroplasts, the biosynthesis of nitrogenase FeMo-co using proteins synthesized in mitochondria, and the expression of functional nitrogenase components in transgenic rice. We discuss the importance of organelle targeting, the exploitation of natural diversity and engineered proteins, and synthetic biology tools for the assembly of multigene pathways. Finally, we present the main remaining obstacles, such as the assembly of functional NifDK in plants, integration with host metabolism and coordinated regulation, and we outline the prospects for the development of nitrogen-fixing crops.
Summary
Zinc is an essential micronutrient at low concentrations, yet it becomes toxic at slightly higher ones. This is exploited by plants as an effective defensive strategy. However, the molecular components that are involved zinc-mediated immunity remain poorly defined. Here, we show that mixed-linked β-1,3/1,4-glucans naturally ocurring in microbial and grass cell walls and used as an agrobiological solution, trigger zinc accumulation in the Arabidopsis apoplast and upregulate the expression of the zinc transporters HMA2 and HMA4. This response occurs independently of salicylic acid, jasmonic acid and ethylene-mediated signalling pathways, but it requires the LysM receptor kinases CERK1, LYK4 and LYK5, indicating a specific pattern triggered immunity-associated mechanism. We further demonstrate that hma2hma4 mutants display constitutive activation of a broad set of defence-related genes, yet this transcriptional reprogramming is insufficient to confer resistance against the necrotrophic fungus Plectosphaerella cucumerina BMM. Moreover, metabolomic profiling highlights the contribution of specialized metabolites to this defective defence output. Altogether, our findings reveal that zinc-mediated toxicity constitutes a defence mechanism integrated into the immune response triggered by specific microbial or damage associated molecular patterns.
Funder Information Declared
Hundreds of proteins in the cell require iron (Fe) or Fe-containing cofactors to function. However, how Fe2+ or Fe3+ are specifically allocated to each of these proteins in plant cells remains largely unknown. It has been proposed that Fe metalation could be driven by specific interactions with Fe-shuttling proteins known as Fe-chaperones. Here, we present the first family of plant Fe2+-chaperones (ICHAPs) with orthologues in dicots and monocots. The role of these proteins in Fe distribution to Fe-dependent metabolic processes has been illustrated using symbiotic nitrogen fixation in Medicago truncatula root nodules. ICHAP1 is a soluble Fe2+-binding protein that interacts with plasma membrane Fe2+ transporter NRAMP1, but not with symbiosome Fe2+-transporters. ICHAP1 mutants present altered Fe distribution in cells and they cannot fix nitrogen. A second family member, ICHAP2 is required to target Fe2+ to symbiosomes, as it accepts Fe2+ from ICHAP1 and interacts with symbiosome Fe2+-importer VTL8, but not with NRAMP1. These results indicate a path for Fe2+ allocation from the plasma membrane to the symbiosome through specific protein-protein interactions and Fe2+ exchange from NRAMP1 to ICHAP1, to ICHAP2, and to VTL8.
Funder Information Declared
Summary
Engineering nitrogen fixing crops requires not only transferring the nitrogenase structural genes, but also the accessory genes to synthesize its iron-sulphur cofactors. Scaffold protein NifU is a critical element in this system as the starting point of nitrogenase cofactor assembly. NifU has been successfully produced in plants, however, its optimal production required high levels of iron in the medium. This is likely due to a faulty connection with the endogenous iron trafficking network
To identify specific elements targeting iron to NifU, pull-down assays were performed to identify showing bacterioferritin A (BfrA) as a likely candidate. Co-immunopurification, mutant characterization, iron transfer assays, and co-expression in Nicotiana benthamiana assays were carried out.
BfrA transfers iron to NifU through protein-protein interactions. When these two proteins were co-expressed in N. benthamiana leaves, there was an increase in NifU production. In turn, it led to doubling NifH synthesis, a nitrogenase structural protein that is also required for the synthesis of the more complex nitrogenase cofactors.
Our results provide a new element towards engineering nitrogen-fixing crops. They also underscore the importance of transferring the metal delivery systems when expressing metalloproteins in heterologous systems.
Funder Information Declared
The scaffold protein NifU plays a central role in assembling the precursor [Fe4S4] clusters required for nitrogenase to function. The synthesis of these precursors depends on a catalytic [Fe2S2] group within NifU core ferredoxin domain. Here, we show that the monothiol glutaredoxin GrxD is one of the proteins delivering this cluster to the NifU scaffold protein. Consistently, grxD mutants have reduced nitrogenase activity, the result of altered iron allocation to this enzyme due to a suboptimal [Fe2S2] cluster occupancy of the core NifU domain in the cell. These results also indicate the existence of additional pathways to provide NifU with its core [Fe2S2] group. Biochemical assays show that GrxD unidirectionally transfers [Fe2S2] to NifU through protein-protein interaction. This allows GrxD to restore apo-NifU functionality, enabling proper [Fe4S4] synthesis, and NifH activation. These findings are crucial to understand how iron is allocated to nitrogenase for biological nitrogen fixation.
Funder Information Declared
Understanding how plants fend‐off invading microbes is essential for food security and the economy of large parts of the world. Consequently, a sustained and dedicated effort has been directed at unveiling how plants protect themselves from invading microbes. Major defense hormone signaling pathways have been characterized, the identity of many immune response‐triggering molecules as well as many of their receptors have been determined, and the mechanisms of pathogen‐host arms race are being studied. In recent years, evidence for a new layer of plant innate immunity involving transition metals has been brought forward. This would link plant metal nutrition with plant immune responses and open up possible new strategies for pathogen control involving metal fertilizers instead of pesticides. In this review, we outline our current understanding of metal‐mediated plant immune response and indicate the future avenues of exploration of this topic.
Plants adapt to fluctuating environmental conditions by adjusting their metabolism and gene expression to maintain fitness1. In legumes, nitrogen homeostasis is maintained by balancing nitrogen acquired from soil resources with nitrogen fixation by symbiotic bacteria in root nodules2-8. Here we show that zinc, an essential plant micronutrient, acts as an intracellular second messenger that connects environmental changes to transcription factor control of metabolic activity in root nodules. We identify a transcriptional regulator, FIXATION UNDER NITRATE (FUN), which acts as a sensor, with zinc controlling the transition between an inactive filamentous megastructure and an active transcriptional regulator. Lower zinc concentrations in the nodule, which we show occur in response to higher levels of soil nitrate, dissociates the filament and activates FUN. FUN then directly targets multiple pathways to initiate breakdown of the nodule. The zinc-dependent filamentation mechanism thus establishes a concentration readout to adapt nodule function to the environmental nitrogen conditions. In a wider perspective, these results have implications for understanding the roles of metal ions in integration of environmental signals with plant development and optimizing delivery of fixed nitrogen in legume crops.
Iron is an essential micronutrient for life. During the development of the seed, iron accumulates during embryo maturation. In Arabidopsis thaliana, iron mainly accumulates in the vacuoles of only one cell type, the cell layer that surrounds provasculature in hypocotyl and cotyledons. Iron accumulation pattern in Arabidopsis is an exception in plant phylogeny, most part of the dicot embryos accumulate iron in several cell layers including cortex and, in some cases, even in protodermis. It remains unknown how does iron reach the internal cell layers of the embryo, and in particular, the molecular mechanisms responsible of this process. Here, we use transgenic approaches to modify the iron accumulation pattern in an Arabidopsis model. Using the SDH2-3 embryo-specific promoter, we were able to express VIT1 ectopically in both a wild type background and a mutant vit1 background lacking expression of this vacuolar iron transporter. These manipulations modify the iron distribution pattern in Arabidopsis from one cell layer to several cell layers, including protodermis, cortex cells, and the endodermis. Interestingly, total seed iron content was not modified compared with the wild type, suggesting that iron distribution in embryos is not involved in the control of the total iron amount accumulated in seeds. This experimental model can be used to study the processes involved in iron distribution patterning during embryo maturation and its evolution in dicot plants.
Global climate change has already brought noticeable alterations to multiple regions of our planet. Several important steps of plant growth and development, such as embryogenesis, can be affected by environmental changes. For instance, these changes would affect how stored nutrients are used during early stages of seed germination as it transitions from a heterotrophic to autotrophic metabolism, a critical period for the seedling’s survival. In this perspective, we provide a brief description of relevant processes that occur during embryo maturation and account for nutrient accumulation, which are sensitive to environmental change. As examples of the effects associated with climate change are increased CO2 levels and changes in temperature. During seed development, most of the nutrients stored in the seed are accumulated during the seed maturation stage. These nutrients include, depending on the plant species, carbohydrates, lipids and proteins. Regarding micronutrients, it has also been established that iron, a key micronutrient for various electron transfer processes in plant cells, accumulates during embryo maturation. Several articles have been published indicating that climate change can affect the quality of the seed, in terms of total nutritional content, but also, it may affect seed production. Here we discuss the potential effects of temperature and CO2 increase from an embryo autonomous point of view, in an attempt to separate the maternal effects from embryonic effects.
Cu+-chaperones are a diverse group of proteins that allocate Cu+ ions to specific copper-proteins, creating different copper pools targeted to specific physiological processes. Symbiotic nitrogen fixation carried out in legume root nodules indirectly requires relatively large amounts of copper e.g. for energy delivery via respiration, for which targeted copper deliver systems would be required. MtNCC1 is a nodule-specific Cu+-chaperone encoded in the Medicago truncatula genome, with a N-terminus Atx1-like domain that can bind Cu+ with picomolar affinities. This gene is expressed primarily from the late infection zone to the early fixation zone, and is located in the cytosol, associated to plasma and symbiosome membranes, and within nuclei. Consistent with its key role in nitrogen fixation, ncc1 mutants have a severe reduction of nitrogenase activity, and a 50% reduction in copper-dependent cytochrome c oxidase activity. A subset of the copper-proteome is also affected in the mutant nodules. Many of these proteins can be pulled-down when using a Cu+-loaded N-terminal MtNCC1 moiety as a bait, indicating a role in nodule copper homeostasis and in copper-dependent physiological processes. Overall, these data suggest a pleiotropic role of MtNCC1 in copper delivery for symbiotic nitrogen fixation.
The Azotobacter vinelandii molybdenum nitrogenase obtains molybdenum from NifQ, a monomeric iron-sulfur molybdoprotein. This protein requires an existing [Fe-S] cluster to form a [Mo-Fe3-S4] group, which acts as specific molybdenum donor during nitrogenase FeMo-co biosynthesis. Here, we show biochemical evidence supporting the role of NifU as the [Fe-S] cluster donor. Protein-protein interaction studies involving apo-NifQ and as-isolated NifU demonstrated their interaction, which was only effective when NifQ lacked its [Fe-S] cluster. Incubation of apo-NifQ with [Fe4-S4]-loaded NifU increased the iron content of the former, contingent to both proteins being able to interact with one another. As a result of this interaction, a [Fe4-S4] cluster was transferred from NifU to NifQ. In A. vinelandii, NifQ was preferentially metalated by NifU rather than by the [Fe-S] cluster scaffold protein IscU. These results indicate the necessity of co-expressing NifU and NifQ to efficiently provide molybdenum for FeMo-co biosynthesis when engineering nitrogenase in plants.
Iron is an essential nutrient for all life forms. Specialized mechanisms exist in bacteria to ensure iron uptake and its delivery to key enzymes within the cell, while preventing toxicity. Iron uptake and exchange networks must adapt to the different environmental conditions, particularly those that require the biosynthesis of multiple iron proteins, such as nitrogen fixation. In this review, we outline the mechanisms that the model diazotrophic bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii uses to ensure iron nutrition and how it adapts Fe metabolism to diazotrophic growth.
Co2+ induces the increase of the labile-Fe pool (LIP) by Fe-S cluster damage, heme synthesis inhibition and “naked” iron import, which turns cell viability cumbersome. The N2-fixating bacteria Sinorhizobium meliloti is a suitable model to determine the roles of Co2+-transporting Cation diffusion facilitator exporters (Co-eCDF) in Fe2+ homeostasis because it presents a putative member of this sub-familiy, AitP, and two specific Fe2+-export systems. An insertional mutant of AitP showed Co2+ sensitivity and accumulation but not Fe2+ sensitivity, despite AitP being a bona fide low affinity Fe2+ exporter as demonstrated by the kinetic analyses of Fe2+ uptake into everted membrane vesicles. Co2+ sensitivity was increased in double mutants lacking AitP and Fe2+ exporters but this did not correlate with the Co2+ accumulation, suggesting a concomitant Fe2+-dependent induced stress. Growth in presence of sub-lethal Fe2+ and Co2+ concentrations suggested that naked Fe-import might contribute to Co2+ toxicity. Supporting this Co2+ induced transcription of Fe-import system and genes associated to Fe homeostasis. Analyses of total protoporphyrin content point to Fe-S cluster attack as the major source for LIP. AitP mediated Fe2+-export is likely countered via a non-futile Fe2+-import pathway. Two lines of evidence support this: i) an increased hemin uptake in presence of Co2+ was observed in WT vs. AitP mutant and ii) hemin reversed the Co2+ sensitivity in the last. Thus simultaneous detoxification mediated by AitP, aid cells to orchestrate an Fe-S cluster salvage response avoiding the increase in the LIP caused by disassembly of Fe-S clusters or naked iron uptake.
Importance A cross-talk between iron and cobalt has been long recognized in biological systems. This is due to the capacity of cobalt to interfere with proper iron utilization. Cells can detoxify cobalt by exporting mechanisms involving membrane proteins known as exporters. Highlighting the cross-talk, the capacity of several cobalt exporters to also export iron is emerging. Although biologically less important than Fe2+, Co2+ induces toxicity by promoting intracellular Fe release, which ultimately causes additional toxic effects. In this work we described how the N2-fixating rhizobial cells solve this perturbation by clearing Fe through a Co2+-exporter in order to reestablish intracellular Fe-levels by importing non-naked Fe, heme. This piggy back ride type of transport might aid bacterial cells to survive in free-living conditions were high anthropogenic Co2+ content could be encountered.
Symbiotic nitrogen fixation carried out by the interaction between legumes and rhizobia is the main source of nitrogen in natural ecosystems and in sustainable agriculture. For the symbiosis to be viable, nutrient exchange between the partners is essential. Transition metals are among the nutrients delivered to the nitrogen-fixing bacteria within the legume root nodule cells. These elements are used as cofactors for many of the enzymes controlling nodule development and function, including nitrogenase, the only known enzyme able to convert N2 into NH3. In this review,we discuss the current knowledge onhow iron, zinc, copper, and molybdenum reach the nodules, how they are delivered to nodule cells, and how they are transferred to nitrogen-fixing bacteria within.
BRUTUS links iron with legume-rhizobia symbiosis
Abstract
BRUTUS is an iron sensor that negatively regulates iron uptake when iron is sufficient. New work shows that BRUTUS orthologues in legumes positively regulate the establishment of symbiosis with rhizobia on the basis of iron availability through mono-ubiquitination of their transcription factor target.